User Center:
Login or Register
advertisement
image

PLAY TIME: Spirit, a dog found injured at the Wythe County Animal Shelter, is recovering well from his leg amputation at the home of his adopter, Sarah Dutton of Ceres. Photo by Jean Farley


Advertisement

‘Spirited’ discussion


Wytheville Enterprise: News >
Wed Oct 31, 2007 - 03:07 PM

By NATE HUBBARD/Staff

Spirit has moved on to the normal blissful life of a young puppy, but people involved in the discovery of the injured dog at the Wythe County Animal Shelter are still seeking “Justice for Spirit.”
John Witt, who first found Spirit on Oct. 6 lying untreated in the shelter with a severely broken and infected left hind leg, created an online petition about two weeks ago with the above title.
The document is addressed to the Wythe County administrator and calls for anyone responsible for Spirit’s suffering to lose their job. The section of the Code of Virginia that was violated in the incident also is included in the petition along with Spirit’s condition when Witt discovered him.
“We have to speak for the animals,” wrote Nanette Rossi, a Wythe County Humane Society member, in a comment on the petition.
Spirit’s injured leg was amputated on Oct. 13.
The petition has revealed that Spirit’s treatment disturbed people from coast to coast. As of Wednesday at noon, the request had 292 signers from 24 states and Canada.
Witt said he publicized the document by posting fliers around town and sending e-mails to organizations he has worked with in getting animals transported for adoption.
With a wide range of contacts, he said he expected to get responses from surrounding states such as North Carolina and Tennessee, but he said he was surprised to see that people from as far away as California, Montana and Illinois had signed the document.
After the initial controversy broke out in the week following the discovery of Spirit, members of the Wythe County Humane Society and other concerned citizens had a meeting with County Administrator Cellell Dalton and Assistant County Administrator Stephen Bear to discuss the situation.
Both sides reported that it was a positive meeting, but Witt said Tuesday night that he created the petition to demonstrate the depth of concern in the community.
“Basically this is just to add to get the community somewhat involved,” he said.
Witt said the county never divulged who precisely it planned to hold responsible for the incident, so he kept the petition open-ended instead of specifically naming people he wants to see fired.
Although most petition signers have expressed their feelings in non-confrontational terms, a few have left comments that call for extreme action.
“thats crap should tie there legs and leave them in pen with no way to get food or water and see how it feels,” wrote a petition signer named Jason from Winnipeg, Canada.
Witt acknowledged that he found some postings on the petition inappropriate, but said that people have a reason to be angry.
“For the most part most of them are legitimate concerns,” he said. “It’s one thing to make a mistake, but this was neglect.”
While Witt declined to target any particular person for dismissal, a few people specifically commented on the petition against the actions of Wythe County Animal Control Officer Danny Blanchett.
“If you ever have a broken bone Danny make sure you let it get infected and sit around until it has to be amputated, you should be ashamed!” wrote Stephen Price of Dublin.
When reached Tuesday afternoon, Dalton said that he was not aware of the petition. He also has not yet received documentation he requested of accusations made by the Humane Society during the meeting about Spirit.
Without having seen the petition, he said that he couldn’t comment much on how it would affect him, but added that he would certainly take people’s concerns into consideration if they are genuine and documented.
He also said that while the described scope of the petition was impressive, he would most value the opinions of area residents.
“I think it means more to me if they are local people and what local people are thinking about,” Dalton said.
Slightly more than half of the signatures – 161 – have come from people identifying themselves as Virginia residents.
Many of the out-of-state signers seemed knowledgeable about the situation, but others included incorrect information in their postings.
“Ridiculous. Would you let a baby suffer like that, Wayne Co?” wrote Ashley Gardner of Charleston, S.C.
Dalton, who has acknowledged wrongdoing by the county, said he couldn’t give any more specifics on the actions already being taken against employees responsible for Spirit’s maltreatment, citing state personnel laws.
He did add, though, that the shelter is improving.
“Since we’ve discussed [Spirit], we’ve had several animals with injuries that have gone straight to the vet,” Dalton said.
Witt said that he doesn’t have a specific number of signatures he wants before formally presenting Dalton with the petition. He also said he still doesn’t have a set plan on when he will close the petition.
Neither Witt nor Sarah Dutton, who adopted Spirit, has visited the shelter in the last few weeks.
Dutton said, though, that she has spoken to a few people who have told her conditions seem to be getting better.
In addition, a contract between the Humane Society and the county finally has been agreed upon which will allow the group to again transfer dogs out of the shelter to foster care as they await adoption.
On Wednesday morning, Dutton, the Humane Society vice president, said she planned to add her signature and take the contract to county officials later in the day.
While both sides continue to work at improving their relationship, Spirit has settled into his new life at Dutton’s home.
“His leg has healed beautifully,” she said. “He’s completely well – and almost house broken.”
And Dutton plans to use Spirit to help heal others through the “Cold Nose Warm Heart” program.
“As soon as he gets older we plan to use him for pet therapy,” she said.
Nate Hubbard can be reached at 228-6611 or .

Reader Reaction:

Please sign this petition if you agree with it.

Posted by John Witt from Wytheville  on  10/31  at  06:38 PM

It is deeply distressing to see case after case of abuse and neglect in shetering facilities. These same acts, essentially of cruelty, if committed by a citizen would result in criminal charges.

So these animals are “rescued” by animal control officers simply to be dumped into a hellish prison environment with almost none of the basic comforts that animals need and deserve?

We must ask ourselves why this happens? Are the shelter employees inherently cruel people. Probably not. The problem lies in the sad fact that our society fails to place enough value on these animals to provide adequate funding and resources to the shelters and their employees.

Spirit’s is not an isolated case. This is happening all over the country, every day. And when it does, the shelters routinely explain away the fact that animals are allowed to linger in agony with untreated wounds and illnesses by saying that they just don’t have the money to treat them. 

Shelters need to take responsibility, but so does the public. If we find Spitit’s story horrifying, as we should, then we need to change the way our city councils fund animal control. We also need to stop producing litter upon litter of unwanted pets who are thrown away like so much trash, overtaxing an already exhausted shelter system.

Just because we don’t see this doesn’t mean we shouldn’t care.  As Albert Schweitzer said, “Think occasionally of the suffering of which you spare yourself the sight.”

Posted by Laura from North Carolina  on  11/01  at  08:47 AM

Is this the correct petition?
http://www.petitiononline.com/spirit01/petition.html

Posted by Dan East from Wytheville  on  11/01  at  09:26 AM

I volunteer with Space Coast Feline Network in Florida and network with many other rescue groups throughout the US, and this situation is heart-breaking! ... Where was Spirit’s HUMANE treatment? If the people there are not held accountable and responsible, then we’ve truly done a disservice to all animals and undermined their trust and needs.

Respectfully,
Kathy Bean

Posted by Kathy M. Bean from Palm Bay, FL  on  11/01  at  11:23 AM

Allowing any animal to lie with an untreated injury is a violation of federal law and, I would hope, also is a violation of Virginia state law.  I know it would be in my home state of Illinois.  In addition to someone or multiple someones losing their job(s), there also should be criminal penalties with jail time.  Come on, Virginia.

Posted by Teri Kidd from Illinois  on  11/01  at  01:43 PM

People who have a total disregard for animals should not be hired and placed in a position as their caretakers.  I am sure there are many people who are deeply concerned about animals that would like to be hired by shelters.

Posted by JoAnn Scholl from North Plainfield, New Jersey  on  11/01  at  02:13 PM

Thanks Dan, that link is correct, not sure why the link did not show on my message above. http://www.petitiononline.com/spirit01/petition.html

Posted by John Witt from Wytheville  on  11/01  at  03:26 PM

Would you leave your dog at this shelter? What if he/she was picked up injured and was left to suffer and maybe die because they refused medical treatment? I just read a inspection report from September 27, 2007 that this shelter was in non-compliance on several areas, this is one of them. I quote the Inspector “ Adequate veterinary care is not provided to stabilize animals that are ill or injured. At the time of the inspection, a dog was maintained in the pound with an untreated eye condition, and discussions revealed that funding for veterinary care is not available for these animals. The pound is required to provide the all of the elements of adequate care, including veternary care, for each aniaml in custody that is suffering from an illness or injury.” Animal Pound & Shelter Inspector. This was a non-compliance! Then just 8 days later Spirit was taken in and left untreated with a severly infected broken leg! This is a pattern that needs to stop!

Posted by John Witt from Wytheville  on  11/02  at  08:58 PM

I have posted the State Inspection report from September 27, 2007 at the following link. Several violations 8 days before Spirit. http://www.je923.com/misc/puppy.html

Posted by John Witt from Wytheville  on  11/02  at  10:17 PM

I just find it sad that our local shelter is being portrayed in such a negative manner.  I personally do not know the Animal Control Officer but I would hope that he is at least compassionate.  I can’t imagine taking that job and not have some compassion for these poor abandoned dogs.  I have a dog that I rescued from our shelter when Bill Ward was in charge.  I think he truly loved these animals and was concerned for their well being.  I hope that Danny Blanchett is the same.  If not we need to find a new animal control officer.

Posted by Vanessa Hedrick from Rural Retreat  on  11/03  at  05:39 AM

We deal with the same kind of issues here in KY. The rural pound here is not a shelter but is a DOG POUND. I have seen absolute horrors come out of this place.
Spirit’s story does NOT surprise me because I have seen the same things,and worse, with my own eyes. It does sadden me though, because there seems to be no end in sight.
We have to reach the masses and reach the children. The hope for the future is in teaching the children NOW to be compassionate.
Thank you for taking Spirit in. I only wish all the hurt, neglected, abused, burned, tortured, tormented, mangy, emaciated animals in Appalachia can find the same fairy tale ending.

Posted by Julia Sharp from Morehead, KY  on  11/03  at  05:35 PM

This kind of thing happens everywhere, because people do not care.And the ones who do are overworked and underpaid. In hospitals,nursing homes,animal shelters and where ever care is to be given. Do unto others as you would have then do unto you.

Posted by James Sawyers from Rural Retreat,Va  on  11/03  at  11:14 PM

This sort of cruelty and much worse happens far too often all over the country and all over the world.  As long as people continue to see animals as “property” and/or “unfeeling animals” this cruelty will continue.

Posted by Diana J. Reiter from Rogers, AR  on  11/04  at  02:14 AM

I am outraged to see the direction that animal shelters take these days. It seems that most, not all, are in the business of making money at the expense of already unfortunate creatures, and they turned into animal prisons, as if these animals are there to get punished. What a shame for america....

Posted by Rebeca Miles from Rochester, NY  on  11/04  at  05:41 AM

I was just reading through the minutes for the County Board of Supervisors from Sept 11, 2007.  A Ms. Ruthy Murray came before the board, and brought up various issues concerning the animal shelter.

The Humane Society is no longer allowed to help with adoption of animals in our county, because of the inability of Wythe County to provide a reasonable contract that the Humane Society can agree to.

I’m sure the Humane Society works with hundreds of government organizations throughout the United States, so I’m curious what it is about the Wythe County Supervisors that is so hard to deal with.

One demand of the county was quite ridiculous: If the Humane Society places an animal, and the animal is returned back to the animal shelter, then the Humane Society has to pay the costs for destroying that animal.  Personally, that bothers me on multiple levels.  Is our county that hard-up for cash, or are the supervisors simply concerned about nothing but money?  Isn’t the Humane Society helping out by getting the animal placed in the first place, even if it is only temporary?  Why should the Humane Society be penalized when the animal was the county’s burden in the first place?  Finally, the Humane Society doesn’t want any animal they place returned back the the animal shelter - they will place it in a new home instead.

Ms. Murray also made mention of three dead animals found recently at the county animal shelter, but Danny Blanchett took issue with that.  Since she did not see the dead animals personally, Blanchett apparently doubted the truthfulness of her statements.

You can read the minutes yourself here:
http://www.wytheco.org/docs/bosminutes/bosmin070911.pdf

Here is a directory of all the minutes.  I didn’t go any further back than Sept 11 to see what other animal shelter issues there were:
http://www.wytheco.org/docs

Posted by Dan East from Wytheville  on  11/04  at  02:24 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Comment on this story:
Registration Required
SWVAToday.com requires that you be logged in in order to post comments. Please log in or register to leave your comment.
<< Back to main